Independent reviews of baseball and softball pitching machines, matched to age, ball and backyardHow we make money
Comparison

Louisville Slugger Blue Flame vs Black Flame

Two spring-arm machines that need no power. The Black Flame is a little faster and sturdier.

Buy the Blue Flame for players 5 to 9 at about $200, and the Black Flame for about $220 if you want up to 50 mph with hardballs, a steel frame and a high fly-ball attachment.

Updated November 19, 2026 · By the editors of Pitching Machine Report · We earn from qualifying purchases

Blue FlameBlack Flame
Real-ball speed18 to 45 mph18 to 50 mph
Light ballsUp to 60 mphUp to 60 mph (Lite-Flite)
FrameLighter tripod, about 12 lbSteel
ExtrasGrounders and pop fliesInterchangeable high fly-ball part, two ground stakes
WarrantyNot listed by retailers60 days
PriceAbout $200About $220

Which to buy

The extra 5 mph matters once a player is 9 or 10 and facing 45-plus mph from 46 feet. For younger players, the Blue Flame is lighter and does everything you need. Neither has a motor, so an adult feeds every ball. See our Blue Flame review.

Questions

What's the difference between the Blue Flame and Black Flame?

The Black Flame throws hardballs up to 50 mph versus 45, has a steel frame and adds a high fly-ball attachment, for about $20 more.

Do the Blue Flame and Black Flame need batteries?

No. Both are spring-powered and hand-fed.

Keep reading