Is Hitting Off a Pitching Machine Good Practice?
Yes, for timing and volume. Less so for reading pitchers.
Hitting off a pitching machine is good practice for timing, strike-zone discipline and repetitions at a controlled speed, but it can't teach reading a pitcher's arm or deception, so mix machine rounds with live pitching and tee work.
What machines do well
- Many strikes at a set speed.
- Speeds higher than a parent can throw.
- Repeatable sessions, so you can measure progress.
What they can't do
- No windup or release to read.
- Less movement and variety than a pitcher, unless you have a multi-wheel machine.
- Grooving one speed can build a one-timing swing.
Getting the most from it
Vary speeds and locations, keep rounds short and finish with situational rounds. See drills.
Questions
Do pitching machines ruin swings?
Not if you vary speed and location. Grooving one speed for hundreds of swings can.